I had a discussion with the maintainer (@gsantner) of memetastic (https://github.com/gsantner/memetastic/issues/87) whether the app should be flagged or not.
The description of “Non free addon” is “This Antifeature is applied to apps that, although Free Software themselves, promote other non-Free applications or plugins.”
All non-free memes has been moved to a seperate github repo and are not included in the apk. They can be downloaded from github via the app.
Arguments for flagging:
- The non-free memes are mentioned
- In the second sentence of the description
- In every screenshot in fdroid
- In the “Download latest assests” popup in first start. This popup does not mention, that the memes and network service are non-free
Arguments against flagging:
- The app itself does not contain non-free memes
- The app can be used with own pictures or with the two prebundled free memes
- The user does not have to download the non-free memes